Oil Industry I (Readings): Prices, Fundamentals, and Big Oil Futures
Needless to say oil prices are occupying everybody's mind right now - particularly since you can't go down the street without seeing $4/gal gasoline prices. Congress is holding hearings to chastise the speculative excesses with "inside baseball" players using the correlation is causation argument to prove widespread evil-doing. My favorite bloggers (BigPicture, CalculatedRisk) and financial writers (Jubak, Mauldin) have all put together excellent summaries recently that are worth reviewing. And of course the MSM (WSJ, NYT, et.al.) is covering the issue extensively. So here's our collection which we've been putting together for a couple of weeks now, and for which the time seems ripe.
The basic argument, which we plan in expanding into an analysis in a follow-on Part II, is the fight between fundamentals and speculators. As you skim over the readings below you'll find a wide sampling of sources and informed opinions but here's our take. Of the ~ $150 price/barrel target price the long-term fundamental price is in the $80-100 range. Another big chunk of that target is caught up with geo-political risk factors. And a third with speculative feedback on short-turn prices. Let's say that the proportions are roughly 60% fundamental, 20% risk and 20% speculation.
Except for one thing. The basic structure of the oil industry is that the major cost drivers are exploration and production; then distribution and processing (refining). As oil has gotten more scarce in inexpensive and readily (politically) accessible areas of the world there are non-linear rising costs to the two fundamental drivers. That's lead to a fundamental and long-term supply-demand imbalance as new oil production hasn't been keeping up with new oil demand and consumption. A partial result of that long-term dynamic of skating on the margin is that the system has been and is increasingly vulnerable to shocks as its' fragilities grow.
That's been the basic dynamic for at least three decades only it's gotten much more pronounced in this century. HOWEVER....there is another fundamental shift well underway that is greatly exacerbating all these innate structural characteristics.
Not only are new oil sources in increasingly hard to get to areas but the bulk of the world's known and potential reserves are no longer market priced nor controlled by private companies. Rather they are controlled by national oil companies or other political entities. Who's priorities are NOT long-run profit maximization.
Worse yet for those reserves controlled by political entities they are milking existing reserves to fund socio-political priorities and significantly under-investing in maintaining current flows while not developing new ones.
There are two bottomlines here:
1) oil is likely available but is getting increasingly scarce at prices we're comfortable with; i.e. the $80-100 baseline structural price, which shifted up from $40-50 in the last ten years, is likely go toward $150+. 20% X $150 = $60. 2 X $60 = $120. $150 + $120 ==> ~ $300 oil !
2) because oil is depletable and demand is growing there is a long-term scarcity premium that's being increasingly reflected in the base (cf. Prof. Hamilton's discussions below). In other words there is a rising scarcity rent being built into l.t. prices that's feeding speculation.
So below you'll find readings on the short-term and long-term pricing factors as well as the impacts on gas prices and the survivabilities of the refiners, or refining operations. You'll also find some fundamental re-thinking about the future prospects of Big Oil as we know. Which is pretty good though it generally doesn't reflect these deep structural changes evolving in the fundamentals of the industry....yet....other than by symptom.
The next steps of course are diagnosis and treatment....otherwise known as a National Energy Plan. Yeah, right.
Continue reading "Oil Industry I (Readings): Prices, Fundamentals, and Big Oil Futures" »


