Brown Shoots, Weak Markets, Resilient Business ?
We're going to take a quick pass thru the economic situation, markets and - picking up on last
post's theme's - talk a bit about business resilience or not, as the cases may be, with examples. Last week's payroll employment data seems to have convinced folks that what we've been saying for months about non-existent green shoots, a weak outlook, a drawn-out recovery and a de-leveraged jobless future is in fact what's the outlook. Interestingly you need to tear yourself away from the US and major foreign business and financial news and listen to BNN; in the readings you'll find some selected vidclip URL's that are NOT there by accident and we highly recommend them all but especially the two *** ones. The market has bounced on PEs not on earnings and that's the story of the moment with the longer-term implications of all this still being struggled with. As we've tried to make clear this is a matter of responsive adaptation in the shorter run and adoptive innovation in the long. Also in the readings you'll find some specific cases on how well that's working and the brave new world we're all facing. The NYT did provide a superb graphic slideshow illustrating how a business cycle works which, if you'll click thru on the graphic, you'll be taken to. Watch it and think about it. We've talked about business cycles a lot and even provided a tutorial earlier so were particularly happy to see this; a superb use of new technology that gets the story right (NB: we've also notice that the YoY meme is really getting much wider spread use as well !).
Back to the Future: Employment & Consequences
This little gem of three composited charts tells multiple inter-locking stories with the top part showing the YoY% changes in Employment and Unemployment since 1998 monthly. Like we've been saying, a leveling off in the rate of decline is NOT a recovery, and you can see both the steepness and depth of the decline as well as the slight leveling - though Unemployment continues to worsen. Folks are starting to pick up on the differences between unemployment in folks actively looking for work and those pushed out of the labor force (Many Left Uncounted in Nation's Official Jobless Rate). That rate of unemployment is 16.3%. Those points are reinforced in a longer-term context in the 2nd sub-chart which shows Employment dropping -4%, Hours Worked -6% and Unemployment increasing by 70% !!! If you think the consumer is coming back any time soon think again. Worse yet the 3rd sub-chart gets back to our long-running theme about how weak job creation was during the recent "recovery" (reaching almost -4 million jobs in the hole) and how disastrous it's become. We're now about -12 million jobs in the hole. REALLY think about that - how long will it take to even get back to breakeven ? Bearing mind that unemployment will keep increasing for some time - perhaps thru all of next year ? What can we say except OMG X 2. First time for the numbers and second because almost nobody gets it.
Market Realities Return
The green shoots and China will save us theories led to a major bear rally between March and May though we've gone nowhere since then. In the last few days (largely on BNN again admittedly) we've heard pundit after pundit talk about the same things we've been jabbering away at. And in the last week we've seen a bunch of market analysis on the likely breakdowns in the market, for which you'll find another bunch of URL addresses to reinforce that point. If there's one must watch please watch the online vidclip presentation of MarketClub's tool demo assessing the SP500. Wonderful. Here's two SPX charts compounded to make our points, which are nearly identical. As you can in the top chart the critical level is about 880, which we busted yesterday on weak volume. If that keeps up, depending on how earnings run, then we can expect things to run down. But where ? In the lower sub-chart we look for some natural limits using Fibonacci limits. A first bottomline here is that you should be on the sidelines - as we said last major market post - take your money off the table ! The next stopping point is ~840, which we consider likely. If that's breeched the downward momentum will build and running down to 780-790 is highly likely. Depending on how things look, the news is running and what the sentiment is that might be breech as well. If that happens then we're back in the where's the bottom in a long-run sense. A question extensively previously considered but if you want to look at an updated long-term chart click thru. Which we recommend and you can't say you haven't been warned ! :)
Business Reactions and Performance
Recent earnings estimates have been extensively revised downward, which you can see by consulting the S&P Earnings Estimates. They're calling for earnings of $55.54 and $74.02 in '09 and '10 with PEs of 16.55 and 12.42, which leads to estimates for the SP500 of 919. In other words a flat market at best, though if you use our Graham-Dodd approach lower PEs, like 10 or less, are appropriate. But even so that's telling us two major strategic things, actually three. 1) There's a lot of risk in valuations, 2) the recent runup was the limit for two years (and possibly more if you go with our pessimistic outlook) and 3) real earnings in a terrible economy are going to be the critical determing factor.
Gee, somehow or another we've circled back to business performance, short- and long-run. Our recurrant mantra is understand the strategic context (Economy and Geo-Politics), understand how each Industry is trending and then understand how each company is dealing with the things it cannot control and the things it can, now and for the future. There's a vidclip in the readings of Ivan Seidenberg being interviewed on Rose which is as perfect an exemplar of this sort of balanced thinking. The take on the current secular trends and how Verizon is being positioned is outstanding but the look ahead to the worldwide future of the Telecom Industry is worth the time.
In the readings there are some specific examples for your skimming pleasure. The section starts with some examples like a Greek Shipping company as well as Apple, talks about the Finance Industry which is the exact opposite of an industry adapting well. They're still locked into the way things were, not the way they are or will be. The lack of effective response and thining ahead can only be described as stunning. Then we have Rio Tinto, the Australian mining company who road the commodity boom into worldwide acquisitions sprees starting to spin off pieces as the result of the downturn. Talk about foresight and mis-readings ! NOT !! We spent a whole long post taking apart the Auto Industry but the outlook for sales is abysmal but the triple tsunami is the growing capabilities of the rapidly developing world, e.g. China's acquisition of Opel and the fact that India has turned out a great car in the Nano. Sadly it would appear that the kind of innovative adoptiveness required is more on display outside the developed world than in it. A theme enormously reinforce by Saab's moving to migrate production of the Grippen to Brazil - really.....really....really think about what that says not just about opportunity but about capabilities. Aircraft are among the most complex and demanding products in the world - advanced fighter aircraft are another order of magnitude. Meanwhile pharma sales are going to decline in the developed world so Big Pharma is looking outside the US, which has been its development base since it's founding. Now the Rapidly Developing Economies are very exposed because they are so export oriented to the downturn and future weakness. But in the long run.... ? Well...we'll leave it at that because we think the implications are both obvious and taken apart in depth and detail in the last post.
Continue reading "Brown Shoots, Weak Markets, Resilient Business ?" »





































