Bad Times, Bad Earnings, Bad Outlook: Consumer and Industrial Performance
Well we seem to be running with a theme, the "BAD", in all its' many guises this time around. So we'll continue it as we shift to discussing our first love business performance. Which, at the end of the day, is all about earnings, which in turn is about growth and profitability. Contrary to the headlines even the companies that reported decent earnings this last time around also reduced their outlooks. And it's not just the Finance Industry either, whom we've been beating up right and left along with everybody else, and deservedly so. Or the Auto Industry, whom we'll get in due course. In this post we'd like to concentrate on Consumer and Industrial companies and after the break you'll find Categories on Earnings plus Consumer (TGT, MickeyD's, CostCo, SHLD, and Sony) and Industrial (UPRR, GE, UTX, Boeing, and CAT). None of whom were particularly sanguine though UPRR was perhaps the most optimistic of the lot, with the major rails having re-discovered pricing power. But even CAT flew a few small warning flags.
Profits and Earnings
Just to put it all in perspective let's borrow a couple of charts from Northern Trust's econ team. You need to take a careful think of this chart and maybe even click on thru to the NT review it comes from. What they have to say though is this, "Are we in a recession or are we not? The debate goes on. Take a look at the year-over-year change in operating profits of the S&P 500 corporations (see Chart 1). Profits have declined for three consecutive quarters through the first quarter of this year". Operating earnings back to '90 are about as bad as they've been and it turns out after-tax profits in the Tech Bust and now are the biggest hits going back to '65. Couple that with the last two econ outlook posts and we'd have to say there are still a bunch of wild-eyed optimists on Wall St. Just domestically we expect the pressures to continue to mount but for everybody looking for the foreign uplift - well if the world slows and currency conversions are no longer as favorable, what then ? The word that comes to mind is OUCH !
Elements of Performance: UTX and GE as Exemplars
Last year was the first in history where buybacks exceeded profits for the year and the pressures from the Street to continue that practice are on-going. In fact one story is about Bill Ackman's continuing investment plus pressure on Target to do just that. Judging from these charts and the outlook there couldn't be a worse time - unless of course you're strategic goal is to effectively liquidate the enterprise. Otherwise buybacks make sense only when the stock is significantly under-valued on a long-term strategic basis, instead of buying it in the face of further likely declines. (Market Drivers 3 (Buybacks):Investment, Hiring, Nah...Bonus, Bonus, Bonus !)
One of the companies who turned in an outstanding performance however is United Technologies (UTX) who also had a pretty positive outlook across their divisions and worldwide. Though clearly they're exposed to all the domestic and international pressures we've discussed and may either not be anticipating them, or downplaying them. Aside from good products, insightful marketing and positioning and a significant int'l presence across several different industries at the heart and soul of their performance is "operational excellence". Something we've harped on over and over again. Several years ago UTX found their performance lagging and instituted a major corporate renewal strategy designed to develop, deploy and implement an integrated "operating system". They've been demonstratively successful and, IOHO, could serve as the poster child for the kind of integrated enterprise management system that couples strategy with execution and functions to the overall enterprise. They call their approach ACE for Achieving Competitive Excellence and this composite tells you, reading clockwise from the upper left, what the strategic components are, shows an example of the kind operational detail involved, charts the current deployment status (telling us how far they've got to go and how much sustained effort is required to do this right) and what the impacts have been on measurable performance. A poster child, we're telling you.
On the other hand let's consider GE which continues to get beat up for lackluster stock performance. Largely on the grounds that it's too big, unwieldy and a conglomerate no one understands. One of the reasons we dug into UTX is that it's also a major multi-industry conglomerate who's managed to do pretty well, which should knock most of that particularly argument on it's head. That the analysts can't figure it out is sad given what they're paid to learn it. And we will admit, and have said, that hanging on to NBCU still doesn't make sense within a corporate framework of industrial + finance focus. We'll further admit that GE's failure to look ahead adequately at the economic trends got 'em into serious trouble quarter before last. Nonetheless their challenges have been a couple of orders more daunting than UTX's, and not just because of the size differences. For one thing Immelt inherited much too high a stock price and PE based on the bubble and Welsh effects. For another Jack left a lot of unraveling for Jeff to do in the first several years. Divisions that should have never been acquired or kept needed to be replaced with those more focused on key strategic trends. And GE has done a great job of completely re-vamping and re-positioning itself for those future trends as well as continuing to run tight ship. If you check out the accompanying chart you'll get a sense for what the strategic trends it sees are, how it's re-positioning and how it goes about executing. IOHO Immelt has positioned GE for the way the world's going to look for the next several decades and done so well with speed, force and style. On top of which people also need to understand that much of their financial activities are synergistic complements to the various vertical businesses. By combining a deep understanding of it's customer's business with it's own industry expertise with deep financing pockets it creates a unique competitive advantage.
So as you skim over the excerpts and contemplate your own situation and investment plans you might keep all these factors in mind. With reference to these models if you like (Performance Assessment Basics: Five Fundamental Factors,Masterclass: Buffett on Investing and Business Analysis).
Continue reading "Bad Times, Bad Earnings, Bad Outlook: Consumer and Industrial Performance" »










